A set of quantitative biology laboratory exercises are being
developed in an interdisciplinary effort between the Department
of Biology and the Department of Mathematics and Statistics at
Utah State University. Our goal is to create a series of
quantitative biology labs applicable to students from high
school biology up through advanced (senior) undergraduate
courses. This page gives a brief description of the labs and
associated tools we have prepared.
|
|
|
Directory of Quantitative Labs
|
The following directory of lab exercises are descriptions
of the lab exercises. The description title links to the
actual webpages that are used by the students in the
laboratories while they are doing experiments and solving
quantitative problems. We employ different pedagogical
techniques in different courses. In the introductory
classes we use a combination of small-group problem
solving and enquiry-based instruction. During the lab,
the instructors periodically convenes the class and
discusses the status of the problem solution and
re-focuses the small groups of students working on the
problem. The pages present a series of steps to the
students that must be completed before proceeding
|
to subsequent steps. Since some of the later steps provide answers
to questions asked in prior steps, these latter pages have
boxes to be completed by the students. This strategy
forces students to think about the problem and also provides a
record of the solution.
Some of the pages may be password protected, as a means
of withholding information that students are asked to discover
for themselves. We have found this to be less
successful and are phasing out this method.
If you wish to view a page which
is password protected, send email to Jim Haefner.
|
The Departments of Biology and Mathematics and Statistics have
established a BioMath minor for students in both Departments. The minor requires completion of a team-taught course that
integrates wet-lab experiments with mathematical modeling and
computational analyses. These exercises have not yet been
produced as webpages, but a brief description follows.
|
Introductory Quantitative Labs with Links
|
Osmosis (the diffusion of water across biological
membranes) is taught in almost all introductory biology
laboratories. It is a ubiquitous phenomenon of cells that
can be demonstrated with relatively simple and
inexpensive experiments. A typical laboratory experiment
simply demonstrates the occurrence of the phenomenon. We
extend this classic exercise in hypothesis
testing by adding a predictive mathematical model.
Osmosis is usually treated early in the first term of an
introductory biology course along with diffusion and
plasmolysis. In our labs, the experiment uses a bag made
from dialysis tubing partially filled with water and
known, but variable, concentrations of sucrose. The bag
is immersed in water, removed for weighing, and
re-immersed in water until the next weighing. This is
repeated for 5--6 weighing bouts over a period of about
40 minutes.
The interesting phenomena which the students eventually see are:
(1) water moves into the bag,
(2) the rate of water movement decreases with time as the internal sucrose
concentration approaches that of the outside, and
(3) this rate depends on initial sucrose concentration.
The quantitative problem for the students to solve is to
mathematically describe these observations. To solve this
problem, they must create a mathematical model.
|
Without this quantitative component, an osmosis lab normally
requires 1 lab period, but must be expanded to 2 lab periods to include the new material.
In first lab period, we lead the students to create a mathematical model of a more familiar
phenomenon: cooling of a body that is initially warmer than
ambient temperature. This has two advantages; first, the
students have an intuitive grasp of the process. Second, we
motivate the cooling problem with a real-world scenario: how to
tell if a cougar was shot legally (see the webpage for more
details). With the aid of the lab instructors, the students are
led through the experiments and data analysis to formulate
Newton's Cooling Law for the rate of change of temperature of a
beaker of water.
In the second lab period, students are presented with the
osmosis phenomenon. They perform the weight gain experiment and
are asked to create a model that describes its change. After
the cooling example, they can see the similarities of the two
processes and transfer skills they learned studying cooling to
osmosis.
The webpages, with instructor guidance, lead students through a
series of steps designed to help them solve the problems. The
primary quantitative math skills that students learn are:
graphing data and drawing "best fit" lines, finding slopes
from data plots, transforming data to create linear relations,
and iterating finite difference equations. The math and
inference skills are re-inforced with homework problems.
|
Back to Directory;
Lab Home;
BioMath Home
This is the first of a two-part lab exercise.
Providing a strong motivation for a quantitative problem is
essential to hold student interest. The motivating question that
this series of lab exercises answers is: How much photosynthesis
occurs in a Bear Lake Utah in one day? This lake is a local, clear
lake with which students are familiar and we further motivate
the problem by comparing it to a local, shallow, and very turbid
reservoir impacted by high nutrient runoff from local dairy
operations. We begin by asking students to think conceptually
about the causal factors that limit photosynthesis in natural
environments like lakes. They do this by creating a concept map
(see the webpages) of photosynthesis in a small group activity.
The instructor then leads a class discussion to simplify the
(usually) complex diagrams.
Light is certainly one of the important variables that determine
lake photosynthesis, and the first step in answering the lake
question is to aswer the question: How does light change with
depth in a lake? This lab exercise leads students to consider
two quantitative models of extinction (linear and exponential
|
decrease with depth). The students must use elementary reasoning
and visualization of functions to eliminate one of the
equations.
The remaining equation, the Beer-Lambert Law, is examined
quantitatively using aquaria, dye, and quantum light meters.
Light is shone horizontally through a series of 3 aquaria filled
with water, and light intensity is measured at the light source
and at end of each aquaria. The students are asked to determine
the quantitative differences between water columns with and
without dye. This leads them to the problem of estimating the
light extinction coefficient in the Beer-Lambert equation.
They calibrate this equation using logarithm transformations and
fitting their data to a straight line.
The math skills they use are: graphing data and drawing "best
fit" lines, finding slopes from data plots, transforming data
using logarithms to create linear relations, and iterating
finite difference equations. Homework problems re-inforce these
skills.
|
Back to Directory;
Lab Home;
BioMath Home
The second lab period answers the question with
which the students were originally presented. Once the
behavior of light in the water column is understood, the
students are asked to determine the effect of different
light levels on the rate of photosynthesis. To answer
this, they use Elodea in an inexpensive manometer exposed
to different levels of light. The response variable is
volume of oxygen produced in a finite time interval.
Measurements of oxygen production are performed at fixed
distances from a light source.
In this preparation, the data typically show an
asymptotic relation with increasing light levels (i.e.,
manometers near the light source). The students are asked
to create an equation that matches this relationship.
Again, the students must estimate the coefficients of the
equation from their data. This requires that they again
use a logarithm transformation to create a straight line
relationship.
|
At the end of the two lab periods, the
students know how light changes with depth and how
photosynthesis changes with light.
The last step is a group problem-solving exercise done
out of class to solve the problem of the lake. The
students must synthesize their knowledge of the effect of
dept on light and the effect of light on photosynthesis
to determine the amount of photosynthesis at several
discrete water depths. By adding the photosynthesis at
each depth, they calculate total photosynthesis. As
homework exercises, they are given actual light
extinction data from Bear Lake Utah with depth and area
data to calculate a final answer to the question.
The math skills they learn from this last step are: unit
conversions, summation (integration), synthesizing two
different equations and experimental results, organizing
and performing moderately complex calculations.
|
Back to Directory;
Lab Home;
BioMath Home
This is a three lab exercise that integrates
predator functional responses and optimal foraging. The
motivating question and principle is: "Do fish forage
optimally?"
In the first lab period, the general problem is
introduced with a discussion of the evolution of animal
foraging behavior. This is followed by a discussion of
food item choice when a predator is faced with two items
having respectively high energy content plus long
handling times (juicy hamburgers) versus low energy
content plus short handling times (bags of peanuts). The
discussion addresses the situations when the density of
each is very low and very high.
Once the students' intuition is clear, they perform a
series of experiments that replicate and extend C.S.
Holling's original disc equation experiments using
sandpaper discs thumbtacked to white foam poster board.
See the lab webpage for details. The data from these
experiments are used to estimate handling times and
attack rates. The experiments are performed so as to
produce Type I, II, and III functional responses.
Homework exercises are assigned. Finally, the
experiments are repeated using discs with two energy and
handling time levels at different densities. The results
illustrate that more energy is
|
gained by consuming the
disc type that has the highest profitability (energy
content divided by handling time), even if it has less
absolute energy content.
In the second lab period, the equations for optimal
foraging are developed. These equations describe the
energy gained by three foraging strategies as density of
prey changes. At low density, the strategy to consume
all prey encountered returns the greatest energy rate.
At high density, the strategy to consume only the most
profitable prey returns the greatest energy rate. The
prey density at which the lines cross is the density
where the predator should change its foraging behavior,
if it is an optimal forager.
This is a lot of algebra for the students, so at the end
of the second lab and in preparation and practice for the
third lab period, students measure the handling times of
guppies foraging on Daphnia or brine shrimp (depending on
prey local availability).
In the third week, the theory is tested with experiments
in which guppies are presented with two size classes of
prey at 3 densities. After the experiments, the
instructor engages the students in a discussion of the
original question. The students complete a short lab
report.
|
Back to Directory;
Lab Home;
BioMath Home
|
Intermediate Quantitative Labs
|
This is a two lab period exercise using computer
simulation and lectures. The primary learning goal is to
have students learn and apply basic hypothesis testing
skills. The motivating question is: "Did O. J. Simpson
commit murder?"
The discussion begins with applications of a series of computer
simulations written in Java and delivered over the internet.
These programs simulate sampling from normal distributions with
different means, variances, and sample sizes. The purpose is to
illustrate the resultant cumulative distributions that emerge
for the
|
difference between two samples. These distributions are used to compute the probability that the null hypothesis
is false. Students are assigned homework based on the computer
programs.
In the second lab period, a lecture describes likelihood
functions and develops the fundamental equation for the
likelihood that the DNA left at the crime was observed given
the suspect left the DNA. This begins with a discussion of
conditional probabilities in the context of forensic evidence
and the nature of legal guilt.
|
Back to Directory;
Lab Home;
BioMath Home
The plastochron and leaf plastochron indices are methods to
measure the age of whole plants and individual leaves based on
their morphology rather than chronological age. They have been
particularly useful for detailed studies of whole shoot and leaf
development. Since the indices are based on measurements of
exponential plant growth, they provide an opportunity to
demonstrate the value of applying mathematics to a biological
problem. In this exercise, students are presented the
theoretical basis of the indices followed by practice in
|
calucating the indices for Xanthium strumarium
(cocklebur) plants of various ages. The exercise demonstrates
the potential variability in plant growth and the restuls of an
exponential growth rate.
The quantitative skills emphasized include: graphing and "best
fit" estimates of slopes, logarithm transformations of data,
and drawing scientific conclusions from quantitative data.
|
Back to Directory;
Lab Home;
BioMath Home
This exercise is distributed over several weeks in an
ornithology class. The exercise is assigned to small groups
within the class. The motivating question is: "How can small
birds migrate long distances without eating?"
For example, more than 50 species of small songbirds and even the 3 g.
Ruby-throated Hummingbird fly 1000km (600m) across the Gulf of
Mexico. There are no stopping points along the way to rest or
refuel. This feat is so amazing that for a long time scientists
believed that hummingbirds flew around the gulf and many
birdwatchers believed that they rode on the backs of larger
birds.
The mathematics is presented in a lecture format and results in
basic parabolic relationship between energy consumption and flight
speed. Then, given the amount of energy
|
available at the
beginning of the trans-oceanic migration, the distance that can
be traveled is computed.
To provide an empirical component, each group is given the
thawed carcass of a small bird that migrates across the Gulf of
Mexico. Each group's problem is to determine for this bird
during a spring crossing of the Gulf
1. what is the best choice for V (velocity of flight),
2. what is this bird's range at the best speed,
3. what is this bird's range when flying against a 25 mph headwind and
4. under what conditions (its own physiological state and
meteorological conditions) should this bird initiate
migration?
|
Back to Directory;
Lab Home;
BioMath Home
|
Advanced Quantitative Labs
|
|
|
cell and total bacterial population size increases during the
experiment. As a result, the experiment is analyzed using
the slopes of regressing enzyme activity against bacteria
counts. The slopes are the primary data of interest.
The quantitative component of the lab exercise involves the
statistical analysis of slopes. We present the statistical
theory and spreadsheet manipulations needed to test the
statistical differences among the slopes of different experiments.
The math skills reinforced are: statistical tests, cumulative
probability distributions, logarithm transformations,
spreadsheet manipulations.
|
Back to Directory;
Lab Home;
BioMath Home
Photosynthesis, like most biological processes,
is dependent on temperature.
The question addressed in this lab exercise is:
"What are processes by which a leaf gains and loses heat?" The
two variables examined empirically are leaf size and stomatal
conductance.
This is a two lab period exercise. In the first lab period the
basic equations of heat balance in a leaf are presented. The
physical processes considered are black body radiation,
absorbance, evaporative cooling, convection, and conductance.
Some of these terms have positive or negative contributions and
their sum must equal zero.
After the theory is presented, the following variables
|
are measured in the lab: leaf temperature, vapor pressure,
wind speed, leaf size, stomatal conductance, and absorbed
radiation. Other parameters are known physical
constants or are given to the students.
The students perform an experiment that varies leaf size and
stomatal conductance to determine the temperature of the leaf.
In addition, they use a simulation program that allows them to
vary key variables to observe their effects on leaf temperature.
The primary math skills obtained are: graphing, managing
complex computations, parameter sensitivity analysis, and
drawing conclusions from quantitative predictions.
|
Back to Directory;
Lab Home;
BioMath Home
This is a three part lab exercise with outside computer work.
In the first part, the Michaelis-Menten equations are derived
from the basic chemical rate equations. In the second week,
statistical methods for estimating the two parameters are
presented. This involves a discussion of linear regression.
The main point of the exercise is to compare parameter estimates
for different methods of transforming the Michaelis-Menten equation to a
|
linear form. In outside class homework,
these linear regression estimates of the parameters are compared
to estimates from nonlinear regression using the SAS statistical
package. The third component is an experiment in which students
measure enzyme activity and use the different methods to estimate
the parameters.
|
Back to Directory;
Lab Home;
BioMath Home
This is a 2 lab period exercise in which students physically
simulate organisms colonizing islands of different sizes and
distances from a mainland. Student data are then used to test
the island biogeography theory of MacArthur and Wilson.
In the first lab period, the basic theory is presented to show
that immigration rate decreases and emigration rate increases as
|
the number of species on the island increases. Students solve
for the equilibrium species number. They fit their data to
these lines based on a simulation of island colonization. The
data are obtained by throwing labeled plastic disks (petri dish
halves) at squares delineated by string on a lawn. Overlapping
dishes represent extinctions; disc labels define species.
|
Back to Directory;
Lab Home;
BioMath Home
|
BioMath Minor Quantitative Labs
|
Students creat rules for the spread of a disease in terms of
frequency and spatial extent of infection. Using a plastic
template with hexagons, randomized infected and non-infected individuals
are represented by marks on the template. The infection rules
|
determine the numbers of infected individuals in the next
iteration. Mathematical models of the dynamics of infected
indivdiuals are created, calibrated, and tested with additional
games.
|
Back to Directory;
Lab Home;
BioMath Home
"How long will a leaky bucket leak before the leaky bucket
leaks no longer?" Students are given plastic containers (milk
jugs) in whose side a small hole near the bottom has been
filled. They measure the rate of flow over time and fit these
|
data to a series of models one of which is based on Torricelli's
Law. They are then presented with a new bucket with a different
type of orifice (e.g., rectangular) and asked to predict the
emptying time.
|
Back to Directory;
Lab Home;
BioMath Home
Students design and execute experiments in which yeast are grown
in different initial concentrations of glucose. They measure
|
yeast and glucose over time, and use these data to calibrate
models of the system.
|
Back to Directory;
Lab Home;
BioMath Home
Paramecium aurelia and Didinium spp are grown
together in small containers and their numbers counted daily.
|
Data from these experiments and others form the basis of testing
a family of simple predator-prey models.
|
Back to Directory;
Lab Home;
BioMath Home